While I expected popular brands like Cuisinart and Igloo to take the top spot—both of which you’ll see later in this list—the best overall option turned out to be the Gavasto Countertop Ice Maker from Amazon. Given its compact size and noticeably quiet operation, this ice maker has a surprisingly high production capacity compared to others of similar sizes, making up to 33 pounds of ice in just 24 hours (26 is the typical standard).
In addition to its substantial ice production, this pick has special features that are rare to find in all the same ice maker, including a scratch-resistant layer for durability, an auto-clean function, a drain, and a quick 6-minute production cycle. Even with these features it costs $129, which is actually lower than some other ice maker models with fewer capabilities.
Initially, I saw the Gavasto Ice Maker as a great choice mainly for shared spaces like dorm rooms, where a noisy ice maker might be disruptive, or for office kitchenettes where its large production capacity would come in handy. However, it’s also a great pick for RV or backyard kitchens which tend to get warm during summer.
Due to its thicker, insulated walls, it doesn’t have to work as hard to freeze water or keep ice solid, making it more reliable in warmer environments without overheating or causing ice to melt too quickly. That being said, the extra insulation does make it slightly heavier than most small ice makers, weighing 24 pounds.
£