I tested all the supermarket fish pieS

and the £2.25 winner was as good as any restaurant offering

There’s nothing better than a bit of comfort food and a fish pie is just the ticket. We tucked in to see which came top with ratings out of five.

(or 3 for £7.50)

£3

PRICE

ASDA MEAL FOR ONE FISH PIE

400g

There’s a solid amount of fish in here, which makes it good value for money. 

4/5

SCORE

(£2.25 with Nectar)

£3.25

PRICE

SAINSBURY’S  FISH PIE

400g

I loved the parsley crumb on top – it gave a lovely bite to the sauce. 

5/5

SCORE

(3 for £7.50 with Clubcard)

£3.25

PRICE

TESCO  FISH PIE

400g

I was very disappointed with Tesco’s fish pie, as I could barely taste the pollock in the filling.

2/5

SCORE

£1

PRICE

ICELAND  FISH PIE

300g

Due to its price, I was  very surprised by how tasty and creamy it was, with a decent amount of pollock filling, too.

4/5

SCORE

£3.49

PRICE

LIDL DELUXE  FISH PIE

400g

The filling was so tasty, as was the ciabatta crumb on top. It was seasoned perfectly.

4/5

SCORE

CO-OP TRADITIONAL FISH PIE

400g

The ratio of fish to potato was a bit off, with not as much mash as I’d like. 

3/5

SCORE

(or 2 for £6)

£3.80

PRICE