Meghan Trainor Would Make The Perfect American Idol Judge (But Does She Have What It Takes?)

Meghan Trainor would be the perfect replacement for Katy PerryAmerican Idol, and has what it takes to succeed on the reality singing competition series. Katy was an American Idol judge for seven years alongside Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan. They were the original judges when ABC revived the show in 2018 after it was canceled by FOX in 2016. Now Katy is leaving American Idol to focus on his own music career.

There have been many suggestions as to who should replace Katy American Idol season 23. They include ex American Idol judge Jennifer Lopez, Taylor Swift, Miley Cyrus and American Idol season 22 mentors Jelly Roll and Jon Bon Jovi. In addition, American Idol Alums Ruben Studdard, Clay Aiken, Fantasia Barrino and Jordin Sparks have been mentioned as potential successors to Katy. There are so many great artists to choose from, but Meghan would be the best replacement for Katy for the following reasons.

Meghan really wants to be an American Idol judge

Meghan has tried hard to get a job

In an interview with ET, Meghan expressed how much she wants to come American Idol judge. He said, “I want nothing more in my life than to be an American Idol judge. It’s my ultimate bucket list dream.” Meghan continued, “Please consider me (laughs) on your show. Please, American Idol! Please! I’m ready. All right, yeah, I’d love to.”

In addition, in the episode from See what’s happening live with Andy Cohenshared via YouTube, Meghan shared “I’ve emailed three great people who work in that world and really don’t have a full say, but I’ve pleaded.” However, Meghan has not heard any updates. Meghan would make a great judge because she wants the job badlyand therefore would put his whole heart and soul into it.

Meghan loves American Idol

Meghan has been watching the reality singing competition series since she was a child

American Idol has been a special part of Meghan’s life since she was a child. In his interview See what’s happening live with Andy Cohenhe explained “It’s my favorite show. I’ve been watching it since I was a kid.” It’s important an American Idol the judge respects the show’s legendary history, and as a lifelong fan, Meghan would be able to.

Meghan Trainor is a talented singer and songwriter

Meghan has won a Grammy Award

Meghan is a very talented singer and songwriter which has many hit songs including “All About That Bass”, “Lips Are Movin”, “Marvin Gaye” (a duet with Charlie Puth), “Better When I’m Dancin'” and “Made You Look”. He also won the 2016 Grammy Award for Best New Artist. Meghan knows what it takes to be successful in the music industry, so she would know what to look for during American Idol auditions. He would bring even more expertise to the panel, joining already established judges Lionel and Luke.

Meghan has the support of the American Idol cast

Host Ryan Seacrest and judge Luke Bryan want him as a judge

When Meghan mentors American Idol season 22 Top 12 contestants on Billboard #1 Hits Night, host Ryan Seacrest and Luke gave her their support over Katy in an interview with ET. Ryan sighed, “She was very good. Meghan is also super talented and has a great sense of humor. She’s funny and spontaneous. I love Meghan Trainor.” Luke also sang Meghan’s praises, stating, “I think Meghan has always been really funny. You know, that’s been her brand, to have fun. (She’s) really witty, that’s for sure.”

It is important American Idol the judges and the host are comradeship. When there’s tension between them, it’s hard to watch. This was never more true than it was back in the day American Idol season 12, where Mariah Carey and Nicki Minaj feuded for most of the season. The show was more about their rivalry than the contestants. With Luke and Ryan already involved since Meghan joined the show, she should definitely be considered. Ryan has worked with everyone American Idol jury since season 1, so his opinion should be trusted and taken seriously.

Another woman is needed to judge American Idol

Katy should be replaced by a woman

Katy’s replacement should be a woman. There has never been an all-sex jury in history American Idol. Not only do women bring their own perspective to the show, but Katy proved that having a strong female role model like her can help female contestants succeed. A woman is needed to balance Lionel and Luke, and Meghan is the perfect choice.

Meghan is a successful pop star

Pop needs to be represented on American Idol

Three American Idol The judges must represent three different music genres. With Lionel handling R&B and soul, and Luke coming from the country world, Katy’s replacement must be a pop star like her. American Idol started like Pop Idol in the UK, proving that the show really is looking for the next big pop star. As a pop star, Meghan should take Katy’s place to keep the genre represented.

Meghan has a big personality

Meghan can fill the void left by Katy

all the time American Idol, Katy was known for her big personality. He had many funny moments in the series and kept the audience laughing. Katy was also known for dressing up in elaborate costumes during a Disney night, including Snow White, Ursula, Mrs. Jumbo, Tinker Bell, Ariel, Elastigirl and Cinderella. Lionel and Luke are more reserved, while Katy is brilliant and bold. Like Katy, Meghan is known for her fun and quirky personalityso he would be an ideal choice to replace her.

Meghan was a fantastic American Idol mentor

Meghan mentored the 22 Top 12 of The American Idol season

Meghan was able to participate in the experiences American Idol season 22 Top 12 contestants when he served as their mentor at Billboard #1 Hits Night. As he mentored the top 12 contestants, it was evident that he was invested in their experience and wanted to help them succeed. He’s a big personality, but he didn’t steal the spotlight from them, which is also very important.

In him See what’s happening live with Andy Cohen interview, Meghan said she loved watching American Idol contestants become superstars and follow their journey from their auditions. He said, “I love being a part of their process. I just take too much interest.” Katy’s love for the contestants was evident in her judges, her duets with them during the finals and her American Idol season 22 dress with the faces of every Top 24 contestant from her era on her skirt. Meghan would be such a judge too.

Meghan has reviewed other reality singing competition shows

Meghan has experience in the genre

American Idol wouldn’t be Meghan’s first time working on a reality singing competition. In addition to his work American Idol mentor, Meghan was the judge Australian Idol season 8 in 2023. He was also a coach The Voice UK on Season 9 in 2020 and served as Team Blake Shelton’s advisor Sound season 8 in 2015. Additionally, Meghan was a judge The Four: Battle for Stardom in seasons 1 and 2 in 2018. Meghan has a lot of experience mentoring, coaching and judging, so she is a logical choice to replace Katy.

Meghan wants nothing more than to come American Idol judge. With Katy gone, it’s now time for her to take on the role. With her experience as a pop star and reality singing competition judge, her fiery personality and love American IdolMeghan is the perfect choice to replace Katy. Hopefully, American Idol season 23 welcomes Meghan to the judging panel.

Sources: ET, Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen/YouTube, Meghan Trainor/YouTube, ET, American Idol/Instagram, American Idol/Instagram